top of page

Flock Can Track Your Car. Who Is Watching the Police?

Oct 16
3 min read

A police surveillance tool is only as trustworthy as the people allowed to search it—and the officials willing to audit those searches. This week’s Civic Outlaws follows that question from Georgia to Colorado, Oklahoma, Ohio, and Missouri.


A system built for police work can still be used for personal purposes


A new federal lawsuit filed by Tyler Murkerson alleges that Coweta County, Georgia, sheriff’s personnel used Flock Safety’s automated license-plate-reader network to search for and monitor his vehicle while he was pursuing a civil-rights case against the sheriff’s office. The complaint reportedly describes searches spread across 197 days. Those are allegations, not adjudicated facts, and the defendants are entitled to answer them. But if the audit records say what the complaint claims, the core question is unavoidable: what legitimate law-enforcement purpose justified each search?


The same technology is now being challenged in Colorado by Chrisanna Elser, who alleges that police relied on Flock data to accuse her of stealing a package worth about $25. She says officers would not meaningfully consider her own vehicle and location evidence before issuing a summons; the charge was later dropped. Again, the lawsuit is disputed and has not been reduced to a final judgment. Its importance lies in the risk it exposes: a database hit can become a presumption of guilt when investigators stop treating it as only one lead among many.


The constitutional question has reached the courts


On October 1, 2026, a federal judge in Oklahoma suppressed evidence after finding that a warrantless search of roughly a month of automated license-plate-reader history violated the Fourth Amendment. Authorities said the later vehicle search uncovered about 91 pounds of methamphetamine. The ruling does not mean every Flock search is automatically unconstitutional, and it may be appealed. It does show that the legal issue is no longer theoretical: historical location searches can affect whether major criminal evidence reaches a jury.


Elsewhere, the accountability problem is becoming painfully concrete. Two former Baldwin County, Georgia, deputies were charged after alleged misuse of Flock data. In Ohio, Sharonville Police Lieutenant Walter Cordes was indicted after prosecutors alleged 29 personal searches of a vehicle belonging to someone he knew. These are accusations, not convictions. They are also a reminder that audit logs matter only when someone reviews them—and acts.


Missouri has rules. Now show the public the audits.


Missouri Governor Mike Kehoe’s Executive Order 26-18, signed September 16, 2026, requires state-funded agencies using automated license-plate readers to limit retention, document queries, restrict access to legitimate criminal or life-safety purposes, prohibit commercialization, and avoid facial-recognition integration. The order generally sets a 30-day retention limit unless data is tied to a qualifying active investigation, emergency, or court order.


Those safeguards are a start, but a written policy is not the same thing as enforcement. Who conducts the required reviews? Are supervisors checking every user and every search term? Can a citizen learn whether officers searched the citizen’s plate? What happens to exported screenshots, copied reports, or data placed in another system? If the answer to public concern is “trust us,” the oversight structure has already failed.


Government Employees Behaving Badly


The episode also examines the charge filed October 14 against Riverview, Missouri, police officer Torre Dyson. Prosecutors allege that Dyson took a handcuffed woman to the police station without normal notification, engaged in sexual conduct with her while she was detained, and released her without booking. The criminal charge is an allegation and Dyson is presumed innocent unless proven guilty. The institutional questions are separate and immediate: what did supervisors know, what did the department’s records show, and what safeguards existed for a person placed entirely under an officer’s control?


Civic Outlaws will keep asking for the records behind the official story: complete audit logs, policies, training, preservation records, dispatch records, and unedited video—not a curated compilation selected after controversy begins. Technology can help solve crimes. It can also magnify retaliation, error, and personal abuse. The difference is documentation, independent review, and consequences.



Support independent accountability work


Civic Outlaws is a 501(c)(3) public charity dedicated to informing the public, investigating government conduct, preserving records, and helping citizens and lawyers locate the evidence needed to pursue accountability. Independent investigations require time, records fees, travel, and technical resources. If you believe this work matters, please support it.



This article discusses allegations, pending litigation, criminal charges, and legal commentary. Allegations are not findings of guilt or civil liability. Nothing here is legal advice.

 
 
 

Comments


bottom of page