Who Picks Missouri’s Judges? Accountability, VLT Fees and Records - November 13, 2026
Show date: November 13, 2026. Podcast released November 16, 2026. By Samuel Trapp.
Who controls the choices before the public ever gets a vote? In the November 13 Civic Outlaws program, Samuel Trapp challenges Missouri’s judicial-selection system, then connects that accountability question to video lottery terminal fees, liquor-license pressure, and access to public records.
Samuel’s central criticism is that a governor must choose from a commission’s three nominees, while retention elections let voters reject a judge without choosing a competing replacement. The legal distinction matters: the appellate commission includes three lawyer-elected members, three governor-appointed nonlawyers, and a Supreme Court judge. It is not simply the Missouri Bar appointing every judge. Samuel also questions whether reform genuinely broadens accountability if a new legislative review committee still prefers attorneys.
The strongest defense of merit selection is that screening and retention can protect judicial qualifications and independence from campaign fundraising, party machines, and donor pressure. Moving selection toward elected officials can make responsibility easier to trace, but can also shift influence toward partisan leadership. Neither structure guarantees impartial judges. The useful debate is over transparent selection, meaningful public oversight, and safeguards against concentrated power—not proof of misconduct by any individual.
The program’s closing VLT discussion asks whether legalization would actually leave room for small Missouri operators. Samuel argues that large flat application and annual fees can impose a much higher per-machine burden on small routes than on large operators. His related preparation emphasized retailer choice and practical market access; the detailed new proposal was not fully presented during this broadcast. Supporters of substantial fees can point to oversight costs and financial suitability, but the proportional effect on smaller businesses deserves scrutiny.
Samuel also describes efforts to obtain an actual completed ATC inspection record and disputes over licensing pressure. His account raises questions, not a finding that every challenged action is unlawful. Administrative licensing proceedings are distinct from criminal prosecution: Missouri law provides notice and Administrative Hearing Commission review, and a prior criminal conviction is not invariably required for license discipline. Those safeguards do not answer whether a particular warning was lawful or coercive; the actual notice, record, authority, and review opportunity must be examined.
Sources: Missouri Constitution, Article V §25(a); liquor-license procedure, §311.680; review, §311.691
Civic Outlaws is a distinct 501(c)(3) nonprofit public-interest, public-education, media, investigative, public-records, and government-accountability organization. Listen to the full program, read and share this discussion, and use Donate Now to support that work.



Comments